Five years after the death of Eric Garner at the hands of an NYPD officer, we asked readers their thoughts on current police-community relations.
I think it’s a little better. The community is getting a little closer to the police as they are around a little bit more now. I think the time that passed has helped the healing, definitely. Things are much better now, of course. Crime is down and the police are doing their job.
Gilbert Rodriguez
Norwood
When it comes to the 52nd Precinct, I see they are definitely trying to make a difference. They are coming out here a lot more than they used to. They’re always out here with the community, even up the block. Sometimes you’ll see them hanging out with the kids, playing basketball, and stuff like that. So it’s good to see them in the community and actually caring about the community instead of just policing it.
Sandy Carattini
Norwood
I believe the relationship is a little stronger, but I think the police need more sensitivity training because I feel they value their lives more than the people they’re serving. So I think they need more training to control their anger and their aggressions. I think they should live in the same community they serve. Everybody works in the same community; why shouldn’t the police? If you had a policeman living next door to you, that would be an extra person you could go to for help. The 52nd Precinct is very good; I have no complaints about them. They could look into some of the minor stuff like breaking into cars. This area really isn’t very violent.
Kyle Smith
Norwood
In my opinion the relationship between the police and the community has gotten much worse over the years. It should gradually get better, but that’s not something we have seen. I think it’s a lack of training with certain officers. I think they should all go back for re-training on how they are supposed to conduct themselves and treat the public. I was violated by an officer from the [46th Precinct]. They violated my Miranda rights and in the end I did three days in Central Booking with two fractured ribs. Officers do not know how to react in some situations when it comes to the public.
Carlos Maria
Mt. Hope
Reflecting on this administration’s performance when it comes to directives of equitable treatment between people of color and people of non-color and the NYPD, it remains clear that there is much work left to do. Police relations in black communities continue to create fear and hesitance among residents and visitors. As a criminal justice activist and organizer, it was most disheartening to experience violence at the hands of my own precinct in November 2018. Unfortunately, black bodies continue to be over criminalized for everyday occurrences. We need resources and funding in our communities, not more cages and state-sanctioned violence.
Shanequa M. Charles
Fordham
For the gentleman Mr. Kyle Smith, I respect your views however if I was a cop and off-duty I would not want my neighbors knocking on my door and asking for assistance all the time. I’m off-duty. Do you think you could just knock on your Doctor’s apt. door if you suddenly felt sick? of course not. He would tell you to go an emergency room of a hospital. Also police should not live in the area where they police. I arrest you for rape or robbery and now you are sitting next to me in a Doctor’s office or dentist office? How do you think that would go over with my family or your family with you? Also I’m in Church and you are sitting near me? Ask any legal Aid lawyer who also serve the public – they only speak to you in the courtroom. You cant visit them in their office or expect a return phone call. The reality is we need to better police ourselves than expecting others to do it for us! We also need more prisons to put bad people away from us.