A group of teachers held a rally on Sept. 18, in front of the Bronx office of the Department of Education (DOE) at 1 Fordham Plaza in the Fordham Manor section of the Bronx, to publicize their concerns about the reopening of schools. They say the schools are not prepared to welcome students or staff back. Holding signs that read, “You Can’t Fix a 100-Year-Old Building in a Week! Duh!” and “Under-Staffed, Under-Funded, Under-Valued!” the teachers and their supporters are worried the DOE has not done enough to clean schools, staff them properly for in-person learning, nor equip students with the digital tools necessary for distance learning from home.
The DOE has instituted a plan known as “blended learning” whereby a select number of students will be physically present at school on some days of the school week, and learning remotely from home on other days. Those students in fully remote learning programs started their new school year on Monday, Sept. 14. Other students will start in a staggered fashion, with elementary students returning on Sept. 29, and middle and high schoolers on Oct. 1.
On Sept. 10, the Mayor’s Office issued a tweet, writing, “We’ve inspected every room in every school to make sure there is safe ventilation, and 96% of classrooms are safe and ready. #ReturnToSchool2020.”
However, at a recent Bronx Community Board 7 Education committee meeting, one meeting participant highlighted the challenges of ensuring social distancing at schools like P.S. 94 in Norwood where the school’s cramped conditions and older infrastructure had been an issue, even before the pandemic.
On Sept. 17, after pressure from the United Federation of Teachers (UFT), New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio agreed to a phased-in reopening of schools, dropping his initial proposal regarding DOE layoffs, and instead agreeing to hire at least 2,600 more educators.
We’ve inspected every room in every school to make sure there is safe ventilation, and 96% of classrooms are safe and ready. #ReturnToSchool2020 pic.twitter.com/BIZCs4N0LO
— NYC Mayor's Office (@NYCMayorsOffice) September 10, 2020
However, not all teachers are convinced that it is safe to return to school buildings. Some parents said that promises by the City of cleaner classrooms and blended learning is not enough to allay their fears, from a safety standpoint as it relates to the risk for students and staff of contracting the coronavirus.
Haile Rivera, who is running for the City Council seat in district 14, stood at the Fordham rally with two of his children, Joey, 7 and Beatrize, 5, because he wanted the DOE to know he decided not to send his kids to PS 91 this school year. “Unfortunately, our schools are not safe,” Rivera said. “My kids’ safety, and that of their teachers, and staff, and principal, I am not going to play with.”
At the press conference announcing the agreement, Michael Mulgrew, president of the UFT, assured parents and teachers that the delayed opening of schools would give the DOE enough time to address safety issues. “We have made a promise to every parent, educator and student who walks into our buildings that we are doing what needs to be done to make sure you have your education, but [it] is also safe,” Mulgrew said.
Alexandra Haridopolos is a teacher and UFT delegate who does not feel enough has been done by the DOE even with assurances from the union. She was protesting with a different set of demands. “We’re demanding a full remote start to the school year to keep all of our students and their families safe,” said Haridopolos.
Together with other teachers, she plans to continue protesting. “We’re going to continue to rally in the morning, and inform the community that going to school is dangerous,” Haridopolos said. “We need parents, we need community members, teachers, and other school staff to be sitting with de Blasio and [Schools Chancellor Richard] Carranza, and Michael Mulgrew, making decisions and only then will we trust that the Department of Education can keep us safe.”
*Síle Moloney provided additional reporting to this story.