For the past few years, about 250 dogwood trees have been blooming in what was once an open field covered in green grass. But the fate of those trees has been left dangling like a dead tree limb.
The dogwoods, found along Mosholu Parkway, were planted by the forestry division of the New York City Department of Parks in 2014. An official explanation on why they’re being removed in September is not clear.
But Elizabeth Quaranta, president of Friends of Mosholu Parkland, said she first heard the news by a Parks employee who explained the dogwoods would be removed citing complaints from residents who hadn’t been informed of the plantings. A discovery that the trees had been mistakenly planted on historic landscape was another reason.
A spokesman for the Parks Department noted the parkway appears on the Capital “Legacy Park” list, a status that takes into consideration the consistent look of an area.
Quaranta, who favors keeping the trees, contacted the National Register of Landscape Preservation and was told that they do not have Mosholu Parkway legally registered as a historic landscape, but that it may be viewed so by local residents.
Quaranta now believes that the removal of the trees is solely based on the complaints of a few influential members of the community, members who have yet to come forward. She also suspects some of the complaints may be from older members of the community who recall using the now occupied open field for pastimes like football.
“We didn’t know either that those trees were going to be planted there. However, we welcomed them because they were put there for good reason. And if you move the clock to today, they actually have benefitted us already,” said Quaranta.
The trees have had several benefits including soaking up water from heavy rainfalls that would erode the soil, creating a greener lawn and healthier trees, and less noticeably, absorbing pollutants from the many cars that travel on the parkway daily, according to Quaranta.
Quaranta sees no environmental reason to remove the trees, calling the matter ironic. “Because they [the residents] complained that they weren’t involved in the planting of those trees, does that give them the right to again not involve the rest of the community and take them out just for political reasons? Are we taking them out for political reasons or are they environmental?” said Quaranta.
Talks regarding the dogwood trees are still ongoing, according to Bronx Parks Commissioner Iris Rodriguez-Rosa, who told the Norwood News, “We will continue the dialogue with our elected partners and community stakeholders to determine the next steps.”
In the hopes of putting a halt to any dogwood removal plans, the Friends of Mosholu Parkland has sent a letter to both the Bronx borough president and the Parks commissioner. They will also be circulating an online petition.
I was appalled when I read this story. Do the residents of this area actually prefer an open field to a median with beautiful trees? I would point out that whatever historical significance Mosholu Pkwy has, it has been lost ages ago. It was nearly 20 years ago when the parkway lost a significant number of trees due to an error by a Brooklyn based landscaper. Many trees that had been planted during the Robert Moses era were lost forever. Now that we have a good number of new trees future Bronxites can admire, these residents have the gaul to complain about because they weren’t informed of it. If these so-called influential residents had a half an eye among them, they should complain about the piles of dog droppings, dead birds and squirrels and heaps of trash left behind by people camping out at night and those playing during the day. I applaud the Parks Department and/ or the city for adding trash cans thoughout the parkway and street corners in and around Norwood. However, if they placed dumpsters end to end and located them along the entire parkway on both sides, trash would still be dumped on th ground. Address those issues first, so-called influential neighbors!